The first task is not to defend an idea, but to understand the problem we believe we have discovered.
The difference between spotting an opportunity and imagining a solution
It is easy to start with the thing we want to build: a store, an application, a food brand. That concrete image helps generate enthusiasm, but it can also limit our research. If we take the solution for granted, we will interpret every conversation as confirmation.
Exploring an opportunity means understanding a situation before committing to an answer. Who experiences the problem? Under what circumstances does it arise? What consequences does it have? What do people do today? Why are their alternatives inadequate? The answers may lead to a solution different from the original one, and that is a useful outcome.
IDEO emphasizes observing people and the iterative nature of research and design. The SBA also places market and competitive analysis among the central elements of business planning. Neither reference implies that we must carry out enormous studies before learning anything: what matters is that the questions and evidence are relevant.
1. Define the situation without introducing your product
Compare two statements: “We need a reservation app” and “Small restaurants waste time and make mistakes when organizing reservations through messages and phone calls.” The first contains a solution; the second lets us investigate whether the problem exists, whom it affects, and how much it matters.
A useful initial description includes the person or group, the task they are trying to complete, the obstacle, and its consequences. It also helps to write down what we do not know. For example: “We do not know how many restaurants have this problem or whether they would pay to solve it.”
Do not confuse a complaint with a business opportunity. An inconvenience may be real but infrequent, inexpensive, or tolerable. The next step is to assess its importance in people's lives or work.
2. Identify the relevant people and contexts
Talking about “everyone” rarely helps with research. To learn, we need groups we can recognize by their circumstances and behavior: restaurant owners who personally manage reservations; families who buy prepared food several times a week; businesses that depend on urgent deliveries.
This does not mean imposing a permanent segmentation on the business. It means starting with contexts where we can observe the problem. Two people of the same age can behave very differently; two businesses of similar size can have opposing operational constraints.
Investigate what they are trying to accomplish, when the need arises, what obstacles they face, how they make decisions, and who pays. In business-to-business settings, the person using the solution, the person approving the purchase, and the person responsible for the budget may be different people.
3. Research the existing alternatives
Direct competition matters, but it is not enough. If you propose reservation software, you also compete with notebooks, spreadsheets, phone calls, messages, and even the decision not to accept reservations. If you want to sell healthy food, you compete with restaurants, food prepared at home, and other ways of handling lunch.
Observe what customers value about those alternatives, the money or effort they spend, and the friction they accept. Do not assume that an apparently outdated option is inferior: it may be inexpensive, familiar, and effective enough.
A simple matrix can record the alternative, perceived benefit, limitation, and evidence. Avoid turning it into a list of invented criticisms of competitors you have not tried.
4. Combine qualitative and quantitative evidence
Interviews help us understand motives and circumstances; observation reveals behavior; public data helps estimate size and trends; field tests reveal constraints that do not surface in conversations. Each source answers different questions.
In an interview, ask about specific episodes: “Tell me about the last time this happened to you,” “What did you do?” and “How long did it take?” Questions such as “Would you like my product?” often produce unhelpful answers because they invite people to imagine a hypothetical future.
Record observations, statements, and interpretations separately. “Three people mentioned delays” is an observation; “everyone needs automation” is a conclusion that the data does not justify. Do not extrapolate market percentages from a small, unrepresentative sample.
To keep these categories separate when recording findings, explore how to distinguish observations, assumptions, hypotheses, and evidence.
5. Assess the size and accessibility of the opportunity
The existence of a problem does not mean there is an accessible market. Ask how many potential buyers you could reach, how often the need arises, how much they spend today, how you would contact them, and what constraints affect the purchase.
Market estimates must show their assumptions. If you calculate potential revenue by multiplying customers by price, explain where each figure comes from and why that scenario would be achievable. The total market for a category is not the same as the customers a new business can acquire.
Regulation, location, seasonality, and barriers to entry can also change the opportunity. A local service may have substantial demand overall but little viable demand in the area you can serve.
6. Look for evidence that contradicts your idea
Good research is not about collecting favorable testimonials. Look for cases where the problem does not exist, an alternative works well, or the cost of switching exceeds the expected benefit. Ask what would have to be true for your offering to fail.
An opportunity deserves more attention when we observe a significant need, consistent behavior, and a reasonable prospect of reaching the people experiencing it. That still does not prove your business will work: it prepares the ground for designing and testing a model.
An example: reservations at small restaurants
After observing several restaurants, you discover that some lose track of reservations during peak hours, while others work perfectly well with a notebook. The problem is not universal. You also notice that owners place a high value on avoiding no-shows but do not want to enter data twice. The research suggests focusing on establishments with a certain volume of reservations and exploring a solution that fits their routine, rather than building a generic system for everyone.
What you should have by the end
A description of the problem, the contexts in which it arises, the actual alternatives, observed findings, an explicit estimate of the opportunity, and a prioritized list of uncertainties. If you still do not know who has the problem, the answer is not to build faster: it is to research better.
Connection: the next pillar turns these findings into an offering and a business model. If a later test contradicts what you have learned, you can return here.
When you are ready to turn your findings into a business model, follow the step-by-step Business Model Canvas guide.
Key sources: IDEO [F1], SBA [F5–F6], Strategyzer [F3].
Bibliography and references
Numerical examples are illustrative and do not represent market data. Legal requirements depend on the jurisdiction and industry.
- [F1] IDEO — Design Thinking. https://www.ideo.com/methodology/design-thinking — Desirability, feasibility, viability, research, prototyping, and iteration.
- [F5] U.S. Small Business Administration — Write your business plan. https://www.sba.gov/business-guide/plan-your-business/write-your-business-plan — Market, model, organization, financing, and projections.
- [F6] U.S. Small Business Administration — Fund your business. https://www.sba.gov/business-guide/plan-your-business/fund-your-business — Financing options and considerations.
- [F3] Strategyzer — How to design and test business ideas. https://www.strategyzer.com/library/the-role-of-an-effective-innovation-coach — Design Loop, Test Loop, hypotheses, evidence, and decisions.