A business model explains how an organization creates value, delivers it to a group of customers, and captures part of that value to remain viable. It is not the same thing as a product idea, an advertising strategy, or a price list. The Business Model Canvas organizes these decisions into nine connected building blocks [R01][R02]. This guide helps you compare configurations before committing resources.

First, separate three different decisions

  • Business model: who receives what value, through which resources, activities, partners, relationships, and channels, and with what economics.
  • Revenue mechanism: what is charged for and under which terms: a sale, a period, a usage event, a license, or a transaction.
  • Sales channel: who finds the customer, closes the sale, and delivers the solution.

An app can charge a subscription, sell directly online, and operate with its own staff. Those are three different decisions that must fit together. Use the Business Model Canvas to describe the whole system.

Common configurations and what changes between them

Configuration How value is delivered Characteristic decision and risk
Direct sales Producer or provider sells to the end user Greater customer control; owns acquisition and support
Intermediation or distribution A third party connects sellers and buyers Gains external reach but gives up margin and control
Specialized service People and processes solve specific tasks Capacity and service quality constrain volume
Multisided platform Coordinates two or more interdependent groups Must attract and balance both sides; manage trust
Licensing Grants rights to use intellectual property or technology Must define rights, support, and contractual limits
Franchise Another firm operates under an agreed system and brand Quality control and contractual obligations matter
Hybrid Combines compatible configurations More revenue options, but greater complexity

These categories are neither mutually exclusive nor an official Canvas taxonomy: they help compare designs, not place every business in one unique category. A café can sell directly and also distribute packaged coffee through retailers. A platform does not automatically become profitable by connecting participants [R02][R04].

Step 1. State the desired outcome and segment

Before selecting a pattern, complete: “We help ___ achieve ___ when ___; today they use ___.” Do not assume that everyone using the solution also pays for it. In business purchases, the user, buyer, and decision-maker may be different people. If you lack evidence about the segment, revisit customer segmentation.

Step 2. Sketch two or three delivery alternatives

For each configuration, identify who performs the core activity, controls the customer relationship, owns the required assets, handles returns and problems, and bears the principal cost. An apparently lightweight option may depend on a supplier whose capacity you cannot control. Link each option to the key resources and activities.

If the option depends on a third party, use the guide to selecting suppliers and strategic partners to assess capacity, terms, and possible alternatives rather than assuming they will be available.

Step 3. Compare value, control, economics, and risk

Build a matrix with four columns: expected customer value, control over the experience, contribution per transaction, and third-party dependency. Record the source behind every figure; where evidence is missing, write “unverified.” Do not turn a table of assumptions into an objective ranking. Include revenue mechanisms and economic scenarios in your comparison.

Worked example: three ways to sell lunches

Hypothetical case: Almuerzo Cerca. The investigated need is receiving lunch during a workday without unreliable waiting times. Consider three options:

  1. Own kitchen and delivery. Controls recipes, delivery, and customer contact; requires equipment, coordination, and fixed spending.
  2. Third-party production, direct sales. Reduces initial investment but adds agreements, oversight, and capacity and quality risks.
  3. Sales through an intermediary platform. May improve discovery and payment collection but charges commissions and controls part of the relationship.

We cannot know which option is superior without real quotes, demand, costs, and contractual terms. For example, with a price of S/40, assumed direct variable cost of S/26, and an additional platform commission of 20% of price (S/8), direct contribution would be S/14 versus S/6 through the platform, all else equal. A platform might also replace acquisition costs or change volume, however; that comparison needs additional data.

Warning signs of an incoherent design

Be skeptical of a model promising personalized service while relying on high volume without adequate staff; accepting unlimited returns without budgeting them; or charging recurring fees for a benefit customers need only once. Judge the model as a system, not as isolated boxes [R01][R04].

Common mistakes and limitations

Do not confuse a popular model with the right choice for your segment. “Digital,” “marketplace,” and “subscription” do not establish demand. Franchises and platforms may involve very different contracts and legal responsibilities depending on jurisdiction; this guide is not legal advice. Also distinguish choosing a promising design from validating it: hypothesis testing belongs to pillar 3.

If a configuration depends on particular licenses, contracts, or permits, see how to identify and document legal and operational requirements. Assess the actual activity and jurisdiction rather than inferring obligations from the model label alone.

Comparison exercise before committing resources

Sketch two very small Canvases for the same customer segment: one for direct sales and another for an intermediary. Answer five questions for each: Who collects payment? Who handles complaints? What happens when orders are scarce? Who absorbs a refund? What happens if the main partner stops operating? Calculate contribution without combining the price from one channel with the costs of another. If the design relies on an unknown answer, record the missing evidence and who will obtain it. The right outcome may be not choosing yet, provided the uncertainty preventing a decision is clear.

What you should have when you finish

A table comparing at least two alternatives, a preferred configuration, major costs and dependencies, reasons for rejecting other options, and a list of uncertainties. Next, represent your choice in a complete Canvas. Sources: [R01][R02][R04].

Bibliography and references